National Law Journal: No Fleeting Obscenities Are Planned, House Judiciary Tees Up Subpoena for Unredacted Mueller Report, Fight Erupts Over Who Should Replace Michael Avenatti in Appeal of $454M Verdict


Judge Questions ICE Over 'Stonewalling' of Immigration Raid Docs

U.S. District Judge Rudolph Contreras is mulling an order forcing ICE to turn over the names of agents who were involved... Read More


Willkie's Gordon Caplan Appears in Court to Face College Admissions Charges

Caplan made a brief appearance before the judge. He said, "Yes, your honor" several times, including in response to... Read More

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW

Gorsuch Will Share 'Personal Stories,' From Upbringing to Confirmation, in New Book

By Tony Mauro
Gorsuch will join Justices Clarence Thomas, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer and Sonia Sotomayor who have written... Read More


LASS ACTIONS

Arbitration Gets the Spotlight at Senate Judiciary Hearing

By Ellis Kim
At issue is a system proponents believe helps keep legal costs reasonable, but that opponents believe is being used... Read More

CLASS ACTIONS | NEWS

Fight Erupts Over Who Should Replace Michael Avenatti in Appeal of $454M Verdict

By Amanda Bronstad
Among those filing motions Monday to replace Avenatti, who was charged with extortion and bank fraud last week, were... Read More

LITIGATION | NEWS

House Judiciary Tees Up Subpoena for Unredacted Mueller Report

By Ellis Kim
Rep. Jerrold Nadler said he will first negotiate with the attorney general before issuing the subpoena. Read More

CIVIL APPEALS

US Justice Dept. Rebuffs Fallout 'Lucia' Claims at Supreme Court

By Marcia Coyle
A new appointments clause dispute reaches the justices: What's a "timely challenge?" The U.S. Justice Department has... Read More

SECURITIES LITIGATION | NEWS

Former Fintech CEO to Pay $17M as SEC Targets Inflated Revenues, Pre-IPO Stock Sales

By Ross Todd
According to the SEC, former Jumio Inc. CEO Daniel Mattes caused the mobile payments startup to overstate its revenues... Read More

LAW FIRM PARTNERS | NEWS

Gibson Dunn Practice Leader Tapped as Catholic U Law School Dean

By Ryan Lovelace
Stephen Payne, who chairs Gibson Dunn's Food and Drug Administration and health care practice group, will leave Big... Read More



Associates Assail 'Fraternity Culture' at Jones Day in $200M Sex Bias Suit

The plaintiffs say Jones Day's "black box" compensation model, management and culture have led to systematic discrimination... Read More

House Judiciary Tees Up Subpoena for Unredacted Mueller Report

Rep. Jerrold Nadler said he will first negotiate with the attorney general before issuing the subpoena. Read More



NATIONAL LAW JOURNAL
Supreme Court Brief
POWERED BY LAW.COM
Tony Mauro
Marcia Coyle
Apr 03, 2019
As we enter a brief pause before the next cycle of Supreme Court oral arguments, we offer an early (mostly cleaned up) peek at the profanity-laden briefing in Iancu v. Brunetti, set to be argued on April 15. Plus, scroll down for a look at the effort to unearth documents that could shed light on the role of the Federalist Society and other organizations in recent Supreme Court and appellate court nominations. Tips and feedback welcome: Contact us at tmauro@alm.com and mcoyle@alm.com, and follow us on Twitter at @Tonymauro and @MarciaCoyle. Thanks for reading!
No Fleeting Obscenities Are Planned
Most U.S. Supreme Court briefs don’t make you blush when you read them. But the briefing in Iancu v. Brunetti, set for argument April 15, is most assuredly not suitable for minors.

The case asks whether the statute allowing the government to deny trademark protection for “scandalous” marks violates the First Amendment. Under that law, Erik Brunetti was denied a trademark for his clothing brand FUCT, which he claims actually stands for something: Friends U Can’t Trust.

But FUCT is far from the Brunetti brief’s most off-color bit of terminology.

To prove the trademark office’s inconsistent enforcement of the statute, counsel of record John Sommer listed 34 words that might sound scandalous, only three of which have been handled consistently. It has allowed FCUK, FWORD, and WTF IS UP WITH MY LOVE LIFE? Again, those are mild compared to other unmentionable words and phrases in the brief.

As profane as the brief is, however, Sommer dropped an unusual footnote that will reassure the justices that they won’t have to hear the words he wrote about:

“It is not expected that it will be necessary to refer to vulgar terms during argument. If it should be necessary, the discussion will be purely clinical, analogous to when medical terms are discussed.”

Asked why he included the footnote, Sommer said, “I thought it was appropriate to say, and I didn't have to worry about the word limit.” Sommer, general counsel for an unrelated clothing brand, takes on other clients like Brunetti.
It’s probably a smart move on Sommer’s part. In 2008 and 2012, when the high court heard arguments in FCC v. Fox Television over “fleeting expletives” uttered during live television shows, Sidley Austin’s Carter Phillips (at left) was advised by a court official not to utter the words at issue.

As Phillips told us in January, “Given that the clerk called me (along with the SG) not once, but twice to say ‘The court does not want to hear those words during argument,’ I think there is no chance the court will decide that using FUCT now is okay.”

The Cato Institute also drops f-bombs in its brief to make a somewhat different point: that scandalous speech is valuable to society. Ilya Shapiro, counsel of record in Cato’s latest, trademark “funny briefs,” cites the Bible, Shakespeare and a full range of modern-day cultural examples, including the 2011 bestselling book Go the Fuck to Sleep, which Shapiro, the father of two young boys, told the justices in a footnote that he owns.

The Rutherford Institute and a brief on behalf of New York University law professors Barton Beebe and Jeanne Fromer may also send you to the Urban Dictionary to find the sexual meaning of phrases you never heard before. Counsel of record for the Rutherford brief is Megan Brown of Wiley Rein, and William Jay of Goodwin Procter authored the professors’ brief.
federalist society
New FOIA Suit Targets SCOTUS Nominations
At a Federalist Society meeting in Texas last fall, Leonard Leo, executive vice president of the national organization, thanked Justice Clarence Thomas for coming and agreeing to be interviewed. Thomas, with a hearty laugh, said, "Well, Leonard, since you're the third most important person in the world…."

Thomas undoubtedly was referring to the widespread attention Leo has garnered for his role in Trump Administration judicial appointments to the U.S. Supreme Court and federal appellate courts. Leo and the Heritage Foundation's John Malcolm were credited with building the list of potential Supreme Court nominees for Trump and supporting Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh through the confirmation process.

But now American Oversight, the nonprofit liberal-leaning ethics watchdog, wants to know exactly how important Leo, Malcolm, the National Rifle Association and other groups and individuals have been in Supreme Court and other federal court nominations.

The organization's lawyers on April 1 sued the U.S. Justice Department for failing to respond to three Freedom of Information requests for records related to outside influence in judicial nominations.

“The Constitution vests the authority to appoint judges in the president with the advice and consent of the Senate, not Leonard Leo or other ideological outsiders,” said Austin Evers, founder and executive director of American Oversight, in a statement. “Seeking outside input would be one thing, but the administration's apparent total deference appears to be unprecedented and anti-constitutional. The public should get to see the influence that is being brought to bear on the process.”

A spokesperson for the Justice Department declined to comment.

Donald McGahn, the former Trump White House counsel and now Jones Day partner, has disputed the notion the administration outsourced its judicial selection process. He has often noted that he's long been a member of the Federalist Society.

“So, frankly, it seems like it’s been in-sourced,” McGahn said at a Federalist Society event in Washington in 2017.

Evers is a former senior counsel in the Department of State, where he worked on oversight and transparency matters. Before that, he was a litigator at Williams & Connolly. FOIA and other public records laws are American Oversight's primary tools and have been used to seek documents in a number of controversial matters involving the Trump Administration.

The latest FOIA suit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, requests all records reflecting communications between DOJ and Leo, Malcolm, Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell and staff, Utah Republican Sen. Mike Lee and staff, any of the nine Supreme Court justices and 43 named individuals and organizations.

Daniel McGrath
 and Elizabeth France are counsel for American Oversight.
Clarence Thomas
Supreme Court Headlines: What We're Reading
• Justice Clarence Thomas Stirs Up a First Amendment Squabble Over Libel Law. For decades, media lawyers and journalists had little reason to worry about such a scenario, thanks to the 1964 Supreme Court decision New York Times v. Sullivan. But on Feb. 19, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote an unexpected opinion that unsettled that sense of security. Always the originalist, Thomas wrote that nothing in the text of the First Amendment required the standard applied in the New York Times case, so the precedent should be reconsidered. [NLJ]

• Here's What Big Law Clients Are Saying About ‘Backward’ Obamacare Ruling. Big Law appellate advocates including Joe PalmorePratik ShahSean Marotta, and Caitlin Halligan had a lot to say in amicus briefs in the Affordable Care Act case in the Fifth Circuit, our colleague Nate Robson reports. [NLJ]

• How Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O'Connor Helped Preserve Abortion Rights. "The story of how the first female Justice, Sandra Day O’Connor, dealt with abortion law reveals much about why this issue is so difficult, and why we may be headed back to the age of proverbial back alleys," Evan Thomas writes. [The New Yorker]

• How 12 Court Cases Could Challenge Abortion Access Under Roe v. Wade. "Here are some of the lawsuits that could upend U.S. abortion rights if the high court chooses to hear them." [Politico]

• Supreme Court Rebuffs Anti-Abortion Activists in Planned Parenthood Suit. "The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday rejected a bid by anti-abortion activists to narrow a Planned Parenthood lawsuit accusing them of illegally recording video of abortion providers to try to falsely show the illicit sale of aborted fetal tissue for profit." [Reuters]

• Gorsuch's 'Troubling Dicta' in Death Case Draws Sotomayor Rebuke. Justices Neil Gorsuch and Sonia Sotomayor faced off this week in a Missouri death row case, where Gorsuch declared: "Last-minute stays should be the extreme exception, not the norm." Sotomayor took issue with the statement, "which could be read to intimate that late-occurring stay requests from capital prisoners should be reviewed with an especially jaundiced eye." [NLJ]

• Chief Justice Roberts's Delicate Seat at the Center of a Divided Supreme Court. "The Supreme Court sits at the epicenter of fundamental disagreements about various crucial issues — campaign finance, affirmative action, abortion, gun control, voting rights and the constitutionality of some of President Trump’s most controversial actions—and the stakes are as high as they have ever been. At the center of it all is conservative Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr.," writes Chicago law professor Geoffrey Stone. [The Washington Post]

• Five Things to Know About Justice Kavanaugh and FERC. "With the possibility of FERC Supreme Court litigation on the horizon, an examination of Kavanaugh’s FERC jurisprudence is instructive, especially when combined with a review of his legal scholarship," write Norman Bay, a partner at Willkie Farr & Gallagher and former chairman of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, and Thomas Millar, an associate in the firm’s Washington, D.C. office. [Corporate Counsel]

• SCOTUS Inaction in Zappos Case Continues Circuit Split Over Breach 'Damages.' "The U.S. Supreme Court declined to settle a circuit split concerning if actual and immediate damages are needed to adequately allege an injury from a data breach, leaving some jurisdictions hotspots for data breach class action filings because of a lower threshold for standing." [Law.com]

TRENDING STORIES

Cuomo, Lawmakers Announce Deal on State Budget, Criminal Justice Reforms


NEW YORK LAW JOURNAL

Profits Rise, But Big Law's Middle Class Still Feels the Squeeze


THE AMERICAN LAWYER

NYSBA to Study if Move to Uniform Bar Exam Led to a Rise in Lawyers Unprepared to Practice


NEW YORK LAW JOURNAL

Big Law Associate Who Was Fired at 61 Clears Hurdle in Age Bias Suit


NEW YORK LAW JOURNAL

After 50-Plus Years, Times and Customs Are Changing at Williams & Connolly


NATIONAL LAW JOURNAL



A MESSAGE FROM THE EDITOR

Will the U.S. Supreme Court soon see a new wave of appointments-clause disputes? Time will tell. But in Kabani v. SEC, George Hicks Jr. of Kirkland & Ellis wants the justices to review the issue of what constitutes a “timely challenge” to the appointment of a hearing officer adjudicating a case at a federal oversight board. On the other side, the U.S. Department of Justice recommends that the high court turn down what it argues is a company's untimely challenge to the constitutionality of those officers. Marcia Coyle has the story. Next, a 200-page report released Tuesday by the Massachusetts Gaming Commission states that former general and outside counsel for Wynn Resorts were involved in efforts to conceal sexual assault and misconduct allegations against the company's founder, Steve Wynn. Roy Strom reports.

Check out these stories and others below.
– Lisa Helem, Editor-in-Chief, The National Law Journal

CIVIL APPEALS

US Justice Dept. Rebuffs Fallout 'Lucia' Claims at Supreme Court

By Marcia Coyle
A new appointments clause dispute reaches the justices: What's a "timely challenge?" The U.S. Justice Department has... Read More

GENERAL COUNSEL AND IN HOUSE COUNSEL | NEWS

Wynn Resorts' Ex-Lawyers Helped Conceal Sexual Assault Claims, Report Says

By Roy Strom
The Massachusetts Gaming Commission says a cadre of lawyers helped Wynn Resorts conceal allegations of sexual misconduct... Read More

LAW FIRM COMPETITION | NEWS

Ex-US Steel GC Folsom Joins Manatt in Washington

By Ryan Lovelace
Suzanne Rich Folsom's extensive resume also includes stints at AIG and the security contractor formerly known as Blackwater. Read More

CIVIL APPEALS

Here's What Big Law Clients Are Saying About 'Backward' Obamacare Ruling

By Nate Robson
The filings included unusual alliances, and even saw two Republican states come out against a district court judge who... Read More

LAW FIRM PARTNERS | NEWS

Gibson Dunn Practice Leader Tapped as Catholic U Law School Dean

By Ryan Lovelace
Stephen Payne, who chairs Gibson Dunn's Food and Drug Administration and health care practice group, will leave Big... Read More

CIVIL APPEALS | NEWS

Senior US House Lawyer Will Depart Doug Letter's General Counsel Office

By C. Ryan Barber
The House General Counsel's Office will play a central role in any subpoena fights involving the Trump administration.... Read More

SECURITIES LITIGATION | NEWS

Former Fintech CEO to Pay $17M as SEC Targets Inflated Revenues, Pre-IPO Stock Sales

By Ross Todd
According to the SEC, former Jumio Inc. CEO Daniel Mattes caused the mobile payments startup to overstate its revenues... Read More

Senior US House Lawyer Will Depart Doug Letter's General Counsel Office

The House General Counsel's Office will play a central role in any subpoena fights involving the Trump administration.... Read More

LAW FIRM COMPETITION | NEWS

Ex-US Steel GC Folsom Joins Manatt in Washington

By Ryan Lovelace
Suzanne Rich Folsom's extensive resume also includes stints at AIG and the security contractor formerly known as Blackwater. Read More

IMMIGRATION LAW | NEWS

Judge Sides With Skadden Lawyers in ICE Raid FOIA Fight

By Ellis Kim
The bench ruling came in response to a open records request seeking the names of ICE agents involved in a Tennessee... Read More

CRIMINAL LAW | Q&A

Bank-Robber-Turned-Law-Prof Lands a Starring Role in Criminal Justice Reform

By Karen Sloan
Georgetown law professor Shon Hopwood discusses how he got involved in the Trump administration's criminal justice reform... Read More

CIVIL APPEALS

Here's What Big Law Clients Are Saying About 'Backward' Obamacare Ruling

By Nate Robson
The filings included unusual alliances, and even saw two Republican states come out against a district court judge who... Read More

LITIGATION | NEWS

Judge Won't Name Foreign Corporation Fighting Mueller Subpoena

By Ellis Kim
Chief Judge Beryl Howell did agree to unseal redacted versions of other records in the case, including briefs, transcripts... Read More

COURT ADMINISTRATION

Gorsuch's 'Troubling Dicta' in Death Case Draws Sotomayor Rebuke

By Marcia Coyle
“Last-minute stays should be the extreme exception, not the norm," Gorsuch wrote Monday. Sotomayor was having... Read More

ELECTION AND POLITICAL LAW

Women Lawyers' Group Stands Up for Jessie Liu After DOJ Nomination Scuttled

By C. Ryan Barber
The National Association of Women Lawyers, where Jessie Liu was once a vice president, issued a broad statement Monday... Read More

WEBCAST

A Primer on Ethics Topics Relating to Commercial Litigation Funding

By Sponsored by: Burford Capital
Date: Tuesday, April 30, 2019Time: 2:00 p.m. ET |11 a.m. PTEarn: 1.0 Ethics CreditCost: ComplimentarySponsored by:    In... Read More

RESOURCES

The Ultimate Guide to Drive Law Firm Growth and Client Success with AI

Sponsored by: Intapp
Learn how your firm can apply technologies such as intelligent automation and AI across the entire client lifecycle to win more business, operate more profitably, and deliver higher levels of client satisfaction. Learn More

A Primer on Ethics Topics Relating to Commercial Litigation Funding

Date: Tuesday, April 30, 2019Time: 2:00 p.m. ET |11 a.m. PTEarn: 1.0 Ethics CreditCost: ComplimentarySponsored by:    In Learn More

MORE FROM THE ALM NETWORK

Providence-Aegon RA Joint Venture Pays $63M for FL Multifamily | GlobeSt

The deal, which calculates out to $161,538 per unit) marks Aegon RA’s first multifamily purchase under its recently... Read More

US House Bill Would Open Bank Doors to Marijuana Business | Daily Business Review

Daily Business Review
The bill backed by the House Financial Services Committee is a top priority for the marijuana industry, which has been... Read More

Policy language leads to confirmation of appraisal award over insurer’s objections | PropertyCasualty360

Daily Business Review
A court in Florida has ruled that a first appraisal award was final under the provisions of a dwelling insurance policy. Read More

Here's What Big Law Clients Are Saying About 'Backward' Obamacare Ruling

The filings included unusual alliances, and even saw two Republican states come out against a district court judge who... Read More


WEBCAST

A Primer on Ethics Topics Relating to Commercial Litigation Funding

By Sponsored by: Burford Capital
Date: Tuesday, April 30, 2019Time: 2:00 p.m. ET |11 a.m. PTEarn: 1.0 Ethics CreditCost: ComplimentarySponsored by:    In... Read More

ELECTION AND POLITICAL LAW

Women Lawyers' Group Stands Up for Jessie Liu After DOJ Nomination Scuttled

By C. Ryan Barber
The National Association of Women Lawyers, where Jessie Liu was once a vice president, issued a broad statement Monday... Read More

LAW FIRM COMPETITION | NEWS

Crowley Joins Public Policy Practice at Squire Patton Boggs

By Sarah Tincher
Former U.S. Rep. Joseph Crowley talks about his next steps at Squire, navigating today's political climate, and what's... Read More

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW | ANALYSIS

'Twombly' Leaves Litigants Pleading for Clarification

By By Meegan Hollywood and Nahid Shaikh
In 2007, the Supreme Court decided Bell Atlantic v. Twombly, a once-controversial opinion that now needs no introduction.... Read More

LAW FIRM COMPETITION | NEWS

After 50-Plus Years, Times and Customs Are Changing at Williams & Connolly

By Ryan Lovelace
Last year, Dane Butswinkas still chaired the firm, Kevin Hodges was managing partner, and men were in the majority on... Read More

LITIGATORS

Trump Watch: Behind the Scenes of Negotiating the Mueller Investigation

By Ellis Kim
For months, it was the key question hanging over the special counsel investigation: would President Donald Trump sit... Read More

LAW FIRM MANAGEMENT | NEWS

Washington Wrap: Reed Smith Grows State AG Team; EDNY Vet Joins Barr at DOJ; Hogan's Hires

By Ryan Lovelace
Reed Smith's D.C. presence stands at more than 115 lawyers and counting. Read More

COURT ADMINISTRATION

Gorsuch's 'Troubling Dicta' in Death Case Draws Sotomayor Rebuke

By Marcia Coyle
“Last-minute stays should be the extreme exception, not the norm," Gorsuch wrote Monday. Sotomayor was having... Read More

Women Lawyers' Group Stands Up for Jessie Liu After DOJ Nomination Scuttled

The National Association of Women Lawyers, where Jessie Liu was once a vice president, issued a broad statement Monday... Read More

A MESSAGE FROM THE EDITOR

In our April NLJ magazine cover story, Justice Clarence Thomas used his opinion in McKee v. Cosby to poke at the actual malice standard set forth in the 1964 U.S. Supreme Court decision New York Times v. Sullivan. Nothing in the First Amendment, Thomas wrote, required the standard applied in that famous case. Thus, the precedent should be reconsidered. But is there any real danger that will actually happen? Tony Mauro explores the question. Next, U.S. Attorney General William Barr told congressional leaders that a redacted version of Special Counsel Robert Mueller III’s report on the Russia investigation will be delivered to Congress by mid-April, “if not sooner.” Read more in C. Ryan Barber's story.

Check out these reports and our other favorites from the week below.
– Lisa Helem, Editor-in-Chief, The National Law Journal | Legal Times

COMMUNICATIONS AND MEDIA | COMMENTARY

Justice Clarence Thomas Stirs Up a First Amendment Squabble Over Libel Law

ELECTION AND POLITICAL LAW

AG William Barr Preps 400-Page Mueller Report for 'Mid-April' Release

JUDGES | PODCAST

'Witness to History': A Federal Judge on Growing Up White in the Segregated South


Editor's Picks


Bad News for Alex Jones: Defamation Case Over Charlottesville Theories Gets Green Light

A team from Georgetown Law’s Civil Rights Clinic represents the plaintiff. Read More

Protecting the Privilege in Government Investigations: the Double Bind

Can non-waiver agreements with the government protect the privilege? The courts send mixed signals. Read More

Trump Gets a 4th Judge Appointed to 9th Circuit

By Ross Todd
Bridget Bade was confirmed 78-21 Tuesday. Read More

INTERNATIONAL LAW | NEWS

Mueller Judge Is Asked to Reveal Identity of Foreign Company Fighting Subpoena

By C. Ryan Barber
The special counsel's case is over, and U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell in Washington will hear arguments Wednesday... Read More

LITIGATION FUNDING

'Real Housewives of Beverly Hills' Star Claps Back at Questions About Lawyer Husband's Legal Issues

By Richard Binder
Erika Jayne was asked via a tweet "if she feels the need to cut back on her glam squad" in light of her husband Thomas... Read More

GENERAL COUNSEL AND IN HOUSE COUNSEL | NEWS

Whistleblower Gets Nearly $34M in Duke University Fake Research Case

By Sue Reisinger
A former Duke University lab employee will receive nearly $34 million after the school Monday settled his False Claims... Read More



Comments